THE DECLASSIFIED
COLLECTION
Cart 0
← All articles

Mind & behavior

The missing page 25 of the Gateway report

The CIA's copy of the Army's 1983 Gateway Process report goes from page 24 to page 26. Page 25 exists. This is what it says, where it was found, and what the government said when asked for it.

The short answer

Page 25 was never redacted. It is absent from the copy the CIA scanned and released in 2003. The Monroe Institute, which the report is about, had a complete copy the whole time and made the page public in April 2021. It holds paragraphs 35 and 36 of the report, headed “Left Brain Limitations” and “Self Knowledge”. The full text is below.

What the report is

On 9 June 1983, Lieutenant Colonel Wayne M. McDonnell of Army Military Intelligence submitted a memorandum titled “Analysis and Assessment of Gateway Process” to his commander. It assessed a course of audio exercises taught at the Monroe Institute in Virginia, which claimed to bring students to altered states of consciousness and out-of-body experience. McDonnell drew on physics, holograms and religious imagery to argue that the technique was plausible. The CIA released a scan of the memorandum in 2003.

How to see the gap for yourself

The typist numbered each sheet at the foot. Follow those numbers through the released file and they run in order until the sheet numbered 24. The next sheet is numbered 26, and it opens at paragraph 37. Paragraphs 35 and 36 are nowhere in the file.

Printed page 24 of the Gateway Process report as released by the CIAThe next sheet in the CIA's released file, printed page 26
Consecutive sheets in the CIA's released file: printed page 24, then printed page 26.

The page is not blank, damaged or blacked out. It is simply not among the sheets that were scanned.

How it came back

  • 24 January 2021. The Black Vault posted the report and noted that page 25 had been missing for as long as its editor had known the document.
  • 16 February 2021. Vice published Thobey Campion's article on the report, which by then was spreading on TikTok, and described the gap.
  • 8 April 2021. Vice reported that the Monroe Institute had emailed its reporter the complete report, page 25 included.
  • 14 April 2021. The Institute posted that copy on the Internet Archive, with the page filed separately.
  • December 2022. The copy held by Wikimedia Commons had the page inserted, according to its own upload history.

What three federal offices said

Before the page surfaced, a requester named Bailey Stoner asked the government for it under the Freedom of Information Act.

  • CIA, 11 December 2019. The Agency replied that “our version of the CREST document referenced in your request does not contain the missing page you are requesting” and suggested the Army, “in the hope that they may have an original copy”.
  • Army, 4 February 2020. The Army's FOIA office passed the request to INSCOM at Fort Meade, the command on the report's letterhead.
  • INSCOM, 11 February 2020. It found no record in any of its holdings. On appeal in January 2021 it said its historic records had been transferred to the CIA and no copy remained.

So the CIA pointed to the Army, and the Army said its records had gone to the CIA. The Agency never said it had not received the page, only that its scan does not contain it.

Why is it missing?

Nobody in a position to know has said. One explanation that circulates is that a sheet was lost in microfilming and never removed on purpose. That may be right, but it traces to no named source and no record. The page numbers prove the page is absent. They do not show why.

What page 25 says

The page picks up mid-sentence from page 24, where McDonnell is matching his model of the universe to the Christian Trinity. It gives the Holy Spirit its place, then says his “universal hologram” is an old idea: the Greek labyrinth, the Hebrew Tree of Life and the Chinese spiral are, in his reading, the same picture.

Then he addresses his own colleagues. For “persons in our profession”, he writes, altered states could offer “the means by which to know in a truly objective way”, and to see ourselves within the universal hologram is to “release ourselves from the prison of subjectivity”. The last paragraph opens with “Know thyself” and ends by calling Gateway “a portal” through which a person, after months or years of practice, may pass “in his search to find self, personal effectuality, and truth in the larger sense”.

There is nothing operational on it: no technique, no instruction, no secret. It is the most philosophical page in the report, which is one reason its absence drew so much attention.

Full text of page 25

Transcribed from the Monroe Institute's copy as held by Wikimedia Commons. The report's own spellings and errors are kept.

Absolute as the model around which the evolution of time-space revolves to ultimately attain a reflection of and union with Him. That thought model, which perfectly reflects the essence or "spirit" of the Absolute fits the Christian metaphysical description of the Holy Spirit. Finally, our description of the universal hologram, the Torus of creation and evolution is neither new nor original. Its use as the figure of the universe, of creation developing in evolution is found in various stylized representations in virtually every religious system of antiquity, whether of eastern or western derivation. Whether its the stylized labyrinth once popular in the Helenic world, the spiralized version of the Hebrew Tree of Life or its Hindu counterpart, or the Chinese Spiral Through The Fourfold Powers, the ultimate meaning is the same. Mystics the world over, it seems, have perceived the universal hologram in the same spiral form and have incorporated that intuitive knowledge in their religious writings from antiquity to the present.

35. Left Brain Limitations. Twentieth Century physics would seem to be revisiting insights belonging to mankind as far back as written records can take us. The only difference is that Twentieth Century physics is using a left brain, linear, quantitative style of reasoning to approach the same knowledge which the mystics of old apparently acquired in a holistic, intuitional, right brain style. As a tool in the hands of our left brain culture, Gateway would seem to be a promising method for achieving the intuitive, holistic type of interface with the universal hologram needed to provide the context that thinkers like Einstein have sought in their labors to discover a unified field theory in physics. For persons in our profession whose concerns revolve around strategic issues, tactical questions and matters of managerial form and system, access to a new world of intuitive perception and self reflection would seem to offer, in the long term, the means by which to know in a truly objective way. This is so because the self-imposed limitations to balanced perception and objective logic which our cultural and personal psychological subjectivity imposes when we use the strictly left brain thinking style could be offset by the holistic form of perception associated with altered states of consciousness. To the extent that we come to perceive ourselves fully in the context of that portion of the universal hologram which is the reflection of ourselves, to that extent we release ourselves from the prison of subjectivity.

36. Self Knowledge. It was axiomatic to the mystic philosophers of old that the first step in personal maturity could be expressed in the aphorism: "Know thyself." To them, the education of a man undertook, as its primary step, achievement of an introverted focus so that he learned what was within himself before attempting to approach the outside world. They rightly assumed that he could not effectively evaluate and cope with the world until he fully understood his personal psychological balance. The insights being provided by Twentieth Century psychology in this context through the use of various kinds of personality testing seem to be a revalidation of this ancient intuition. But no personality test, or series of tests, will ever replace the depth and fullness of the perception of self which can be achieved when the mind alters its state of consciousness sufficiently to perceive the very hologram of itself which it has projected into the universe in its proper context as part of the universal hologram in a totally holistic and intuitional way. This would seem to be one of the real promise of the Gateway Experience from the standpoint of its ability to provide a portal through which, based on months if not years of practice, the individual may pass in his search to find self, personal effectuality, and truth in the larger sense.

Printed page 25 of the Gateway Process report, from the Monroe Institute's copy
Printed page 25. Monroe Institute Archives, via Wikimedia Commons.

One more thing wrong with the released copy

Pages 17 and 18 are bound in the wrong order. Page 17 is a diagram of the galaxy; page 18 is the text that discusses it. In the CIA's file the discussion comes first.

In print

The Gateway Process, our annotated edition, prints the whole report with page 25 in its place and pages 17 and 18 in the order the typist numbered them. Each original page faces a readable transcription, with 79 notes, 13 photographs and both FOIA letters reproduced. Paperback $35, linen hardcover $49. See the edition →

Sources and further reading

  1. Analysis and Assessment of Gateway Process ↗

    The CIA's released copy, 29 sheets, without printed page 25.

  2. GovInfo: Analysis and Assessment of Gateway Process ↗

    Official release.

  3. Wikimedia Commons: Analysis and Assessment of Gateway Process ↗

    The copy with page 25 inserted, drawn from the Monroe Institute's copy posted to the Internet Archive on 14 April 2021.

  4. Thobey Campion, Vice, 16 February and 8 April 2021.
  5. The Black Vault, 24 January 2021.
  6. CIA and INSCOM replies to Bailey Stoner's Freedom of Information Act request, 2019 to 2021.

Open the released file at page 24 ↗

Read the records

The Gateway Process ↗

Continue reading

The Army report that approached altered consciousness through sound and physics